Economics and net returns can make strange bedfellows during weird and wonderful economic events. Stagflation has been one of the possible scenarios touted as a consequence of the sub-prime mess, which is just a more complex form of hyper inflation that also brings low growth rates. Those looking to make money in a hyper inflation environment observe a myriad of paradoxical concepts, most notably the fact that both traditional investing and holding money as cash are both poor options on paper. The usual reaction from the crowd is to invest in secure interest-bearing deposits, like CD’s. As usual, the crowd calls the situation incorrectly. Stable asset growth may look attractive, but at the end of the cycle an investor may find he’s actually lost real money (which is much different to what he thinks he’s making when he receives his quarterly statement). CD rates often fail in beating inflation during these scenarios, and the only way to protect your money in relative terms is to place it somewhere that utilises the effects of inflation.
Mish in his economics blog outlines some potential asset classes:
- In hyperinflation the last place one wants to be is in cash.
- Commodities in general are a standout.
- Gold is a standout.
- Precious metals are a standout.
- Property is a winner.
- Equities are a winner.
- Treasuries are distinct losers if not an outright short.
- Foreign currencies
- Energy
The standout asset for someone looking to expand their net worth and take some risks is without a doubt, property. During periods of high inflation, economic theory says that the value of money is moved from lenders to borrowers. This is good news for those with a mortgage, as repayments now become lower relative to the new value of money. Another benefit is the opportunity to increase rental rates at the price of inflation. This allows the property owner to price fix his cash inflow amounts according to market conditions — a luxury not possessed by stocks or bonds. The anomaly that exists is whether property prices will rise or not. Considering a hyper inflation scenario may be the product of stagnant housing prices, the idea is starting to look less like an easy proposition. Mish says it best:
Is there a catch? Why yes there is. One needs to be able to make mortgage payments on the loan. That means the timing of the hyperinflation better be spot on. It also means that property values better keep on rising from the moment the leverage is taken or income must rise enough to afford the mortgage if it does not.
Should ever one get in a position via excess leverage to not be able to sell the asset for more than one paid while not being to afford the mortgage payment, foreclosure or bankruptcy occurs. Losing a job ad being underwater on leveraged property is an instant enormous headache.
In order to beat your mortgage payments and make money on the investment, housing prices need to climb higher. As the property markets becomes more fragile, its apt to one making a 6:1 roulette bet, but with only an even money pay out. Much risk for an investment vehicle that is supposed to be defensive. What about the much hyped commodity market? Well, the double edged sword rears its ugly head again. This type of economic environment will probably lead to a slowdown in the US. The rippling effect on emerging economies, the ones eating up resources like Kirsty Alley at a buffet, will likely depress the already over-speculated asset prices. Gold has probably seen the most speculation since the 70’s, and it too is a high risk/low return proposition. Even if the price of gold rises above $1000 in a year, it still means a meager 17% return on its current prices. $1000 gold is the most bullish estimate I’ve seen, too.
Foreign currencies can work (or better still, combining the two with property prices), but once again, you’re hoping the knock on effect doesn’t create too much domestic disruption in your chosen investment currency. Some currencies seem to buckle under pressure, like the Australian dollar did against the greenback during 2000.
So what’s my advice? Wait for the cards to be revealed. No sense making a big bet now, especially during historically unprecedented volatility. Wait for the smoke to clear, then make your move. The thing about inflation spikes is, they usually carry through for at least 3-4 years. Once hyper/stagflation becomes a reality, its usually not too late to plan a portfolio around the new economic conditions. Just remember the fundamentals of debt during high inflation, and beating the markets real returns should be a breeze.